BIKEPGH MESSAGE BOARD ARCHIVE

« Back to Archive
16

Copenhagen's secret weapon

Not really secret...


part 1


part 2


A 200% tax on automobiles. If people don't own cars, they won't use them.


lyle
2010-02-09 23:40:56

I wonder how well this scales. I mean, the population of Denmark is less than NYC.


Perhaps some like-minded folks should try to move to a smallish state here and attempt to secede from the U.S. and start a Denmark-style state/economy, much like the Free State Project.


Update: Apparently you pay 90% on the first 6000 euro of your car purchase. I generally waver on taxation issues (at heart I'm an anarchist, but realistically, I most resemble a Christian Democrat), but the income tax is upwards of 50%. Yoikes. And that doesn't include the VAT. Double yoikes.


Of course, perhaps we have a skewed idea of things, since Denmark is the second happiest place in the world.


bjanaszek
2010-02-10 00:47:29

One of the key things to get from those episodes of planet money, is that corruption exists all the same and even Danish economists agree that the situation they have right now can't last forever and will have to change very soon.


robjdlc
2010-02-10 03:16:28

"Tax and spend" has been vilified in the last few decades in the US.


Thing is, tax-and-spend is fiscally healthy and responsible when compared with Borrow-and-Spend (which seems to be the opiate of the so-called conservatives).


mick
2010-02-10 04:09:20

If what I'm reading is correct, Denmark had very serious debt issues that their currently high taxes were created to fix.


A couple of other random thoughts, because I find this very interesting:


1. Unemployment in Denmark is around 5%, but that only accounts for people who aren't working but want to be working. Has anyone seen numbers regarding the number of people on the dole there? Maybe that's why they're so happy--they're getting paid not to work :-)


2. What if the U.S. implemented heavy taxes on second cars, particularly in families? I don't think our current infrastructure would allow massive taxation on all cars (we have a rather large country, and public transportation is not consistently good, or even okay), but I think it's reasonable to say that a family/couple should pay extra tax on a second car.


Another word on borrow-and-spend--I think it's pretty popular with everyone. Most Americans, regardless of political stripe, don't want to pay more taxes (even if the reality is that many Americans don't even pay much in federal taxes).


bjanaszek
2010-02-10 12:01:47

Over here we pay people to go buy cars, not the other way around...


salty
2010-02-10 16:00:38

I don't mind paying a higher tax rate so long as I get something out of it. Health care, good infrastructure, SNOW REMOVAL, good mass transit etc.


rsprake
2010-02-10 16:32:58

@rprake: ... so long as I get something out of it. Health care, good infrastructure, SNOW REMOVAL, good mass transit etc.


If you can't get those, would you settle for bombing the hell out of some third world country?


Mick


mick
2010-02-10 19:21:28

No, but most of the country seems to. I also support a war tax during times of war or occupation. Maybe then these anti-tax, pro-war people will wise up.


rsprake
2010-02-10 21:22:48

As a 22-year-old, I certainly appreciate how the baby boomers have deigned to spend a few trillion dollars of my generation's money on useless wars.


alankhg
2010-02-10 23:06:11

As a 22-year-old, I certainly appreciate how the baby boomers have deigned to spend a few trillion dollars of my generation's money on useless wars.

Don't worry...given the current state of medical technology, you can rest assured they'll be spending our money for at least the next 20-30 years.


reddan
2010-02-10 23:31:54

You've gotta admit, spending more on "defense" than the next 15 countries combined is pretty impressive. Not just anyone can muster that level of absurdity.


alnilam
2010-02-11 04:29:28

They not only spent a few trillion dollars of your generation's money, they even got a few hundred thousand of you to volunteer to actually go do the fighting.


jkoutrouba
2010-02-11 12:38:20

Being a boomer-geezer, I was hoping you guys wouldn't notice.


Various folks predicted, stating in the early 1990's, that we would face a serious recession about now. It's only expected to last a coupla decades, though.


The peak retirement should happen around 2020-2025. Along with social cesurity, you can expect economic stagnation from a massive sell-off of stock.


I hope there aren't age riots.


Mick


mick
2010-02-11 17:14:07

Whatever happened to "Live fast, die young, and leave a beautiful corpse" of that generation? (and leave something for the kids)?

Or was that my generation? I forgets.


edmonds59
2010-02-11 17:27:28

I hope there aren't age riots.


Me too. Aside from the "you can't hit Granny!" handicap, I expect walkers and wheelchairs would provide a significant advantage in mass hand-to-hand combat.


reddan
2010-02-11 17:36:57