BIKEPGH MESSAGE BOARD ARCHIVE

« Back to Archive
11

Derailleur Issue

Hey all,


I have a Murry mountain bike I got off Craigslist so of course it is not perfect. First of all, when I shift (in either the front or back), the chain takes about 5-10 more rotations for the gear change to happen (I'm not actually sure if this is normal or not) and this is more so for the front gears. It just doesn't feel right to me. Also, sometimes the chain will hit against the front derailleur. When this happens, I push the left shifter forward (sometimes backward, depending on what makes more sense) until this stops. This doesn't usually result in a gear change however. My left shifter is a little smoother than the clicking in the right shifter going from gear to gear. Again, I have no idea if this is normal. So my question is, how can I fix this? I know theres lots of videos and guides out there but I'm not sure what I can trust. I know REI has a basic tuneup that should probably address this but that costs $40. I don't really have that kind of money but if anyone thinks it is worth it, I might look into it.


I have another (simpler!) issue.. when I use the front brake, the right brake pad stays on the tire even after I release the brake. Sometimes the brake will kind of "fall" into this position if I hit bump a certain way too. I know I just have to tighten or adjust something but I'm not sure what.


Any help or advice on anything is greatly appreciated!


bob_loblaw
2009-07-22 01:39:07

your deraileur issue is probably easier solved than the brake one, but both can be solved for free by going to kraynicks bike shop in garfield and asking gerry or one of the people in the back what to do... both should be fairly easy to solve... it sounds like the front deraileur needs tweaked a bit using the adjusting screws on the deraileur and the barrel adjusters on your shifter (if it has barrel adjusters) the brakes probably easy too, but without seeing it its hard to say what it is... go to gerry's


5003 Penn Ave

Pittsburgh, PA 15224

(412) 621-6160


imakwik1
2009-07-22 03:29:09

Hi Bob, I really enjoy your law blog.


Both problems you describe are generally simple enough that they can be fixed by a patient bike repair novice. If you have a couple hours to spare and want to learn, I'd suggest saving the $40 and doing it yourself.


I haven't run into too much bad bike repair advice online. Though, as is true when searching for anything on the internet, I would avoid yahoo answers or about.com. A great place to start is with the late Sheldon Brown's web site: http://sheldonbrown.com/repair/index.html


If you don't have tools, go to Free Ride or, as imakwik1 suggested, Kraynick's and work on your bike there. Print out any directions you think you'll need before you go, as both places tend are often crowded with more people seeking bike repair advice than the limited number of willing bike repair advisors can reasonably help.


If you go the DIY route, one bit of safety advice: any time you mess with your derailleur, before you ride be sure to adjust your derailleur limit screws properly (more explanation here: http://sheldonbrown.com/derailer-adjustment.html).


kramhorse
2009-07-22 06:33:24

Haha you have good taste in television kramhorse.


Thanks for the advice!


bob_loblaw
2009-07-22 10:21:43

So I checked out Kraynicks and I was wondering how bike-friendly Penn Ave is. I only know it as far as the Strip (coming from downtown). Is this this best way to get there from downtown? I checked the route out on Google Earth and used the nifty elevation meter to figure out if there are any crazy hills.... it looks like it gets pretty steep (I'm a novice -- I just started riding again for the first time in years!), but I was wondering what people had to say...


I could drive if I needed to but I really want to get in the habit of biking everywhere.


bob_loblaw
2009-07-22 11:59:19

Look into taking Liberty, it may take you a little bit out of the way, but you have a bike lane to use. The hill is not awful but if you haven't been on your bike in awhile it will hurt the first few times.


rsprake
2009-07-22 13:06:09

The key advantage to Liberty is that there's a lot more room to share with both motorists and cyclists. Penn is narrow and steeper, Liberty is wider and longer.


As for the bike itself - yes, it's normal for the chain to sometimes rub on the front derailleur cage, especially if you're using a combination of gears that is at the extreme opposite range, ie, the big chainwheel in the front and the big cog in the back. Use of those combinations is discouraged as it places much higher stress on the chain and the gears, causing them to wear faster and wasting precious human energy. But even other combinations will sometimes rub a bit, so you "trim" the front derailleur until the rub goes away.


With traditional (old-fashioned) friction shifters, in order to get the chain to change gears, you would "over-shift" slightly and then come back to the proper position. Nowadays, that is built in to the clickety shifter mechanism, but it doesn't always work right, and it's sensitive to adjustment. You should find some threaded barrel adjusters inline with the cables, usually at the shifter, on the derailleur, or at some intermediate mounting point on the bicycle. If you turn these in one direction, you increase the tension on the cable relative to the housing, and the other way decreases it. Or to think of it another way, the adjusters move the derailleur's rest position in and out. I'd say this is like "fine tuning" on your TV, but I haven't seen a TV with an analog tuner in a hundred years.


As for the brakes, you probably need to center them, but it's a harder thing to describe all the possible variations of brake posts and nuts and washers and crap.


Somebody really needs to offer "new to cycling" or "return to cycling" classes. Hm.


lyle
2009-07-22 14:23:32

I take Penn pretty often. It's doable but not pleasant. I wouldn't suggest it until you're comfortable riding again and have driven in the area enough to be familiar with where you'd need to change lanes, avoid potholes, expect cars to make an abrupt left turn in front of you, etc.


kramhorse
2009-07-22 14:58:19

if you are going at a set time this week i could probably manage to be there the same time... should be doing a decent amount of work this week.


imakwik1
2009-07-22 15:09:10

bob, you should get yourself a bike map, available at every bike shop in town (although kraynick's is often out cause he has no room to store overstock): http://bike-pgh.org/campaigns/commuter-bike-maps/


you can at least look at it online there. it will help you find the better roads for riding on


erok
2009-07-22 15:32:15